Robert D White wrote:firstairdriesona wrote:Robert, glad to hear that. of course it still only finds people who were caught. but thats all it can do. its an important CYA step no doubt about it and hopefully just doing it keeps some "people" from aplying as leaders.

It wasn't CYA on the part of Scouts Canada. The RCMP initiated the additional check because of the Graham James issue.
No system is perfect and those who want to harm children seem to find a way around the system (e.g. the latest child abduction in Sparwood, BC). However, the more we do to try and catch these people, the better.
Even more than that, the more we do to try and prevent children being harmed by these predators in the first place, the better. I don't think Scouts Canada can do much more than it does (intake interview, references, follow up by Group Commissioner, PRC). Really, the PRC is merely confirmation, like firstairdriesona stated, that a person never got caught doing anything wrong. As soon as someone with a record knows that a PRC is necessary, then their desire to volunteer will quickly dissipate (unless it is an old, pardonable offense that was more youthful stupidity than anything sinister). It is the intake interview and the references that are the key to keeping predators away from our children. Our GC's and our Section Leaders have to be aware of their gut feelings when conducting the interviews and following up with references. And they really must do these things. I wouldn't hire anyone in my office without checking their references, so why would I let them near the kids for whom I'm responsible without doing the same? VRAD is very, very important, and we must follow it to the letter, especially with regard to following proper screening of potential volunteers.